Tobacco black market: Switzerland relies on unverifiable figures

A new analysis by AT Switzerland challenges estimates of illicit tobacco trade used in political debate. Official data do not provide a reliable picture of the true scale of illicit trade. Nevertheless, figures from tobacco-industry-funded studies have even found their way into a Federal Council report.

In 2025, Swiss customs seized approximately 1.6 million cigarettes, compared with 7.7 billion cigarettes sold legally in the country. Seizures thus amounted to just 0.02% of legal sales. This ratio does not, however, indicate the actual size of the black market, since the proportion of illicit cigarettes intercepted is unknown. A new analysis by the Swiss Association for Tobacco Prevention (AT Switzerland) shows that the available data neither allow illicit trade to be quantified reliably nor demonstrate the existence of a large, organised black market in Switzerland.

Federal Council adopts tobacco industry estimates

Reports prepared by KPMG for Philip Morris International nevertheless estimate that several hundred million cigarettes are traded illicitly. The Federal Council’s December 2025 report cites, among other figures, an estimate of 300 million cigarettes for 2024, associated with estimated tax losses of CHF 76 million. Yet the underlying raw data and several key calculation steps are not publicly available, making independent verification impossible. AT Switzerland’s analysis also stresses that cigarettes purchased legally abroad or in duty-free shops must not be classified as illicit trade.

Unverifiable estimates must not underpin our tobacco tax policy

The threat of a rapidly expanding black market is regularly invoked to oppose higher tobacco taxes. Yet the available evidence does not establish an automatic link between tax increases and growth in illicit trade. A recent British study by Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) reaches similar conclusions, highlighting how the tobacco industry uses inflated estimates of illicit trade to oppose public health measures. AT Switzerland calls on the Confederation to develop reliable statistics and independent estimates that clearly distinguish legal from illicit trade flows. Figures funded by the tobacco industry that cannot be independently verified must not be used as a decisive argument against tobacco tax policies that protect public health.

Transparency and Truth is also publishing a new factsheet today on how the tobacco industry uses the issue of illicit trade to oppose tax increases.Factsheet

Report: Luciano Ruggia (2026), “The black market or illicit tobacco trade in Switzerland: between data, estimates and narratives”, AT Research Series, No. 12. The report is available in German, French and English. An executive summary and a summary factsheet are also available.

Additional source: Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), “Beyond the headlines: the reality of illicit tobacco in the UK”, October 2026. Read the study.Read the study

For further information:
Wolfgang Kweitel wolfgang.kweitel@at-schweiz.ch 031/ 599 10 20

Related articles